Q1: Was the head contacted?
Q2: Was there any other option? Yes? 1 Week
Force level/intent = added penalty.
Past record = penalty adjustment.
Will either fucktard cothin or Ellis get done? No. Even with fucktard cothin being on 2 FARKING STRIKES that he should HAVE BEEN FARKIN SUSPENDED FOR LIKE ZERRET!!! Because this game is farked. 'It’s the shades of grey that ‘make our game so wonderful’.
Garrunteed he’ll get off, as they’ll say his attack was on the ball. Plus they’ll use the Barry Hall rule, and just ignore any incidence leading to the Grand Final.
If you look at it; while his head might be down & he was over the football… Cotchin actually made no attempted to collect the football. His momentum was purely towards Shiel, with his head over the football.
Cotchin has been let off a number of times under the Adam goodes ruling of ‘but he’s good bloke’ case, this season. He should cop a week or two with his current carry over points.
On the other hand, Brendan Ellis should be a garuntee to miss the Grand Final. His hit was thuggish, got the elbow up, chose to bump instead of tackle, and got the GWS in the chin.
I think it’ll play out that Teflon Trent will be suspended by the MRP then get off on a challenge on Tuesday after every biomechanics expert in the land has given dodgy evidence.
For the game:
Adelaide by 21 points.
Castagna first goal
The NSM will go to whoever the fark Hirdy wants it to go to
Richmond celebrated a hell of a lot after the prelim win. A hell of a lot.
Not that I gave anyone except Sydney the slightest chance of knocking off adelaide, but IMO Richmond have already played their grand final just by getting there.
Imagine the irony if Cotchin gets suspended and Richmond ends up appealing to the Supreme Court. Fighting against injustice of the AFL.
Long way to go before this eventuates but it is a little tasty.
Plenty of talk about the TIGER ARMY!!! overcoming all the adversity of being ■■■■ for 30 years and no talk of the crows overcoming the ACTUAL adversity of having their coach brutally murdered.
Cotchin should go for that imo. It was crude and dangerous. Sheil got there first, had his head over it and two hands on it. Cotchin was protecting himself and got him front on. Of course Haneburry got off and Hurley was blamed so in all likelihood they’ll let it slide
Anyone else think it would be karmic justice if cothcin missed the final ??
It’ll be interesting to see how the mrp handle this. He’s pretty much had his 2 freebies this year , like it or not he concussed a player by his attack on the ball , his him high obviously and deserves at least a week.
But will they have the balls to suspend him ??? I’m betting not