#22 - Jake Carlisle: Gone

Probably means little but it’s good to hear that he’s engaged with his team mates and coaches. Could mean anything … when it comes to his footy he’s keen to learn and absorb any info coming his way / he doesn’t want to leave on bad terms / he’s committed to the cause and not leaving the club. Who knows, he’s been adamant about talking contract at the end of the season. He’s wanted to play well to lift his value?

I will personally drive Carlisle to a from Seaford if that means we get pick 5 in this years team. I don’t want to have any social chats to the fark strictly business.

I

Was responding to Donsforever’s post.

I’ve also been told he can’t stand Goddard. The hate for the club however is not what I’ve heard either way.

The Goddard thing makes sense, Goddard demands excellence from himself and others, Carlisle on the other hand…well we all know the answer to that.

Reckon Carlisle is nervous…

Carlisle & Melksham for #5 is a terrible deal for us.

Agreed.

Don’t agree and don’t think it is terrible outcome, just trying to be realistic here.

Although I’d try add saints 3rd rounder, so it’s “Carlisle & Melksham for #5 & #43”.

Carey on 7 pre-game show said Carlisle apologised to the playing group for his comments.

good to hear…

Can someone get a screenshot of barker's face after that win? I've never seen a coach so nonplussed after a victory.
He just realized he might have to keep coaching them
We are still a legit chance for pick 2. Carlton may beat GWS and Gold Coast may beat port......I doubt it though

Carlton would have to beat GWS by a lot or we’d need to cop a couple more beltings for them to catch our percentage

We are still a legit chance for pick 2.
Carlton may beat GWS and Gold Coast may beat port…I doubt it though

A really good result for us. It certainly does not stop Carlton getting Carlisle through the PSD but it just provides some doubt.

Can someone get a screenshot of barker’s face after that win? I’ve never seen a coach so nonplussed after a victory.

Melksham pick doesn’t exist yet, and if Port can’t to better than trying to improve their offer to GC by chucking in pick sixty freaking seven, it might not exist until very late next week.

Carlisle & Melksham for #5 is a terrible deal for us.

Agreed.

Pretty sure Brisbane will pick up Schache if they have pick one. So if Carlton take Weitering the incentive to spend big $ on Carlisle surely isn’t there.
can only be good for us.

Wow. Can’t even tank properly.

Wow. Can't even tank properly.

It doesn’t matter how much you try to, you just can’t out-hopeless Hack Watts.

Cripps doing his absolute best to sabotage the tank. Kreuzer off the ground with a “niggle”.

Why involve the crows? Carlisle and Melksham pick for 5?
Works for me, but for some reason I don't think we are offering this....hmm

I would much prefer 4, 9 & 23 than 4 & 5. It’s a good draft pick for a FOUR pick downgrade. We’ll likely only get one of Parish/Francis anyway. Pick 9 probably gives us a options out of Curnow, McKay, Weiderman or Collins. Top mid, good tall, 2 2nd round picks. Can fix a lot of areas in the side.

But 9 for Carlisle is low. I’d ask for the Adelaide steak knives (Lyons?) or Saints 3rd rounder (2015 or 2016, 2016 preferred).