I was under the impression that the perceived issue with Essendon was that we lacked pace in our midfield. How is a guy with two bung knees gonna fix that?
He's quicker than most of our midfield even with that...
Pre-knees he was an absolute gun. Now he's "just" a good player. He's not at the level of Watson / Heppell or even Zaha but he is IMHO still better as an all-round clearance player ( lateral movement, pace, skills ) than guys like Stanton, Howlett and - just - Myers IMHO.
You know what, we need success. Im fkn sick of mediocre essington. I want a finals win or two, or three. If he can help achieve that over the next few years, is put through the ringer by doc reid and passes his medical (f reid says he’s right, he’ll be right) and comes cheaply, il be all for picking him up. We lack outside run and uf he’s deemed fit he can do that along with being a decent half forward. I say yes
Could be a handy pick-up for a couple of years, especially if Winderlich doesn't play on. By then we won't be dealing with compromised drafts anymore. I'd rate Cooney above Melksham.
I was under the impression that the perceived issue with Essendon was that we lacked pace in our midfield. How is a guy with two bung knees gonna fix that?
He's still quicker than most of what Essendon currently has in the midfield.
Could be a handy pick-up for a couple of years, especially if Winderlich doesn't play on.
By then we won't be dealing with compromised drafts anymore. I'd rate Cooney above Melksham.
Are you quite sure about that?
Cooney a former Brownlow medallist and still has the "smarts" if not the Legs. Would still be a best 22 player at Essendon.
Melksham, well, if 2015 is like most of his first 5 years, then he will definitely have hit list-clogger status. Needs to do vastly more to be a best 22 player.
Could be a handy pick-up for a couple of years, especially if Winderlich doesn't play on.
By then we won't be dealing with compromised drafts anymore. I'd rate Cooney above Melksham.
Are you quite sure about that?
I rate Melksham's disposal, but he's barely best 22 IMHO.