Match Review Thread - Umpires def. Essendon

anyone else notice or bring up early in this thread, the dogs banner ??

If ever you wanted to sum up a pissant clubs lack of knowledge of winning premierships, this picture would be it hahahahahaha

Oh Footscray, you must know sooo much about premierships (and rhyming)…

anyone else notice or bring up early in this thread, the dogs banner ??

If ever you wanted to sum up a pissant clubs lack of knowledge of winning premierships, this picture would be it hahahahahaha

If they would EVER win another grand final I would really like to see how they unfurl a cup at their first home & away.

http://imgur.com/lh7pnHG

Our next banner when we play Footscray with the caption.

“Get The Point”

Is it legal to shepard the man on the mark? Dogs did it a few times and I just can't see how it's allowed
Hawthorn and Collingwood made it legal...not by rule change, but because umpires are too scared to penalise them.

You can’t be in the protected area when play on is called, once play on is called it’s OK. (I think)

That we can’t get this right is like how we still don’t drop the ball straight away if we don’t have prior.

You reckon the dogs player was outside the protected area when play on was called at 50 out?

Is it legal to shepard the man on the mark? Dogs did it a few times and I just can't see how it's allowed
Hawthorn and Collingwood made it legal...not by rule change, but because umpires are too scared to penalise them.

You can’t be in the protected area when play on is called, once play on is called it’s OK. (I think)

That we can’t get this right is like how we still don’t drop the ball straight away if we don’t have prior.

You reckon the dogs player was outside the protected area when play on was called at 50 out?

I don’t know which particular incident you are talking about but I’ll have guess and say the umps got another one wrong.

I still really don’t get the point of the doggies banner… like why you would take the time to supposedly critique an opposition club song… but in the process give a grammar lesson.

I just don’t even…

I still really don't get the point of the doggies banner.. like why you would take the time to supposedly critique an opposition club song.. but in the process give a grammar lesson.

I just don’t even…

FLAG AND UP DON’T RHYME.

doesn’t matter original song doesn’t rhyme at that section anyway. its a ■■■■ banner by a ■■■■ team with a ■■■■ board and ■■■■ fans.

Also worth noting that in Victorian sporting parlance, footy teams win flags, horses win cups.
We have “flag favourites” in September and “cup favourites” in November.

I’ve been enjoying the Doggies banners this year. Admittedly last weeks wasn’t their best effort, but let’s not get too precious, at least they’re trying to come up with something other than the the usual drivel… “Let’s give it our best shot and win!”.

They do realise that not every line has to rhyme, right? Unless, you’re talking about kids songs and rap.

I still really don't get the point of the doggies banner.. like why you would take the time to supposedly critique an opposition club song.. but in the process give a grammar lesson.

I just don’t even…

FLAG AND UP DON’T RHYME.

doesn’t matter original song doesn’t rhyme at that section anyway. its a ■■■■ banner by a ■■■■ team with a ■■■■ board and ■■■■ fans.


I would be equally disappointed if our banner had suggested that they are no longer the “sons of the west” but rather a collection of men from all around Australia that live all around melbourne… perhaps their song should start with “sons of the world”

I mean really… I don’t think I have seen a banner actually try to correct a club song before… plenty of “the bombers will fly down, not up” type stuff but this is just plain weird.

I’m not going to lose sleep over it but I just found it strange… and still do.

Here’s a quote from Wikipedia’s article on the AFL Grand Final:

The premiers are also awarded the "premiership flag", a large pennant which is unfurled at the premiers' first home game of the following season. The current flag is blue with the AFL logo, the word "premiers" and the year of the premiership. Although the cup features much more prominently in celebrations immediately following the grand final, the flag has far greater symbolic significance. This is reflected in football parlance, in which speaking of a team winning the flag rather than the cup is much more common; this is possibly the result of history, as the presentation of the flag first occurred in 1895 when the VFA recognised Fitzroy's first premiership win, while the cup was not introduced until 1959 (retrospective cups were awarded by the AFL in 2010 for VFL/AFL premierships prior to that time).

In other words, as their sole Premiership win was in 1954, five years before the cup was introduced, Footscray have never won a cup, but they have won a single Premiership FLAG.

Pathetic, ignorant cretins.

Can we get Leunig to do ours

I've been enjoying the Doggies banners this year. Admittedly last weeks wasn't their best effort, but let's not get too precious, at least they're trying to come up with something other than the the usual drivel.... "Let's give it our best shot and win!".
it was still a notch better than Freo's inspirational message to its 250 game skipper David Mundy. "Congratulation David Mundy 250 Solid games". Must have run out of crepe paper letters

What sort of career did you have David?
Solid.
What was it like to get confused with Barlow all the time?
Solid.
What’s pav like as a bloke?
Solid.
Poos?
Solid.

I still really don't get the point of the doggies banner.. like why you would take the time to supposedly critique an opposition club song.. but in the process give a grammar lesson.

I just don’t even…

I thought all banners had to be approved by AFL? Do they consider this banter? Pathetic effort, still, did give us a laugh. I think the few intelligent doggies supporters around us just groaned.

I still really don't get the point of the doggies banner.. like why you would take the time to supposedly critique an opposition club song.. but in the process give a grammar lesson.

I just don’t even…

I thought all banners had to be approved by AFL? Do they consider this banter? Pathetic effort, still, did give us a laugh. I think the few intelligent doggies supporters around us just groaned.

yeah they do.. but this wasn't offensive.. just stupid. I guess the AFL doesn't prevent stupidity.. or perhaps they were too embarrassed to explain to the doggies cheer squad what winning a 'flag' actually meant.. considering most of them have realistically never seen one.
Can we get Leunig to do ours

So he can plaster it with anti vax nonsense?

Here's a quote from Wikipedia's article on the AFL Grand Final:
The premiers are also awarded the "premiership flag", a large pennant which is unfurled at the premiers' first home game of the following season. The current flag is blue with the AFL logo, the word "premiers" and the year of the premiership. Although the cup features much more prominently in celebrations immediately following the grand final, the flag has far greater symbolic significance. This is reflected in football parlance, in which speaking of a team winning the flag rather than the cup is much more common; this is possibly the result of history, as the presentation of the flag first occurred in 1895 when the VFA recognised Fitzroy's first premiership win, while the cup was not introduced until 1959 (retrospective cups were awarded by the AFL in 2010 for VFL/AFL premierships prior to that time).

In other words, as their sole Premiership win was in 1954, five years before the cup was introduced, Footscray have never won a cup, but they have won a single Premiership FLAG.

Pathetic, ignorant cretins.

So many people forget this, along with the non mcintyre finals system (ie no grand final) pre 1933’ish.

Here's a quote from Wikipedia's article on the AFL Grand Final:
The premiers are also awarded the "premiership flag", a large pennant which is unfurled at the premiers' first home game of the following season. The current flag is blue with the AFL logo, the word "premiers" and the year of the premiership. Although the cup features much more prominently in celebrations immediately following the grand final, the flag has far greater symbolic significance. This is reflected in football parlance, in which speaking of a team winning the flag rather than the cup is much more common; this is possibly the result of history, as the presentation of the flag first occurred in 1895 when the VFA recognised Fitzroy's first premiership win, while the cup was not introduced until 1959 (retrospective cups were awarded by the AFL in 2010 for VFL/AFL premierships prior to that time).

In other words, as their sole Premiership win was in 1954, five years before the cup was introduced, Footscray have never won a cup, but they have won a single Premiership FLAG.

Pathetic, ignorant cretins.

Do you happen to know why it became referred to as a ‘flag’ and not a pennant like so many other sports at the time (and still) compete for?