My mate was an umpire and he once did not pay a free for the exact same thing as rampe did. When asked why he said that the kick fell short so the shaking didn’t impact the kick.
He was told by his umpiring bosses that that is irrelevant and a free on goal line should have been paid.
There is no grey in this. It is one of the only black and white rules footy has.
We did so much wrong but our unwillingness to rebound out of defence quickly and through the corridor cost us. We did it ONCE in the last quarter, McKenna’s goal. Rest of the time Hurley just bombed it long down the line to a contest we would eventually lose.
We have a small, fast defence, no real key marking forwards yet played as though we had nick reiwoldt leading up to the wings.
Play our ■■■■■■■ game style at least. Run through the ■■■■■■■ middle and take a chance. We simply just got into a “Sydney” game and got smoked for it.
The happy embrace with the losing score framed underneath cuts deep and perfectly sums up our last 15 years. It’s more of a kick in the guts then it should be…I can’t shake it. Extremely disappointing game in so many ways.
It’s unbelievable really. We played like ■■■■ all game and probably didn’t deserve to win, but that rule is plain as day, and the umpires chose to completely ignore it. It cost us the game.
It’s blatant ■■■■■■■ cheating and something needs to be done.
Brereton and Cornes have absolutely unloaded on Essendon on SEN.
Said that the players are absolutely clueless to defensive set-ups and complete lack of leadership on the ground telling younger players where they need to stand defensively.
Cornes said Essendon are nothing more than a tease that will not amount to anything in the near future. People need to stop saying they are anything more than a mediocre middle of the road team, and that’s all they will ever be.
I am concerned the club has lost its way in developing talented players. We should be much better than this. Why?
Back in 2013, include Merrett and Fanta. Merrett is a champion, no question. Fanta is a goal machine, he kicks goals in almost every game. No worries, future looks bright.
BUT from there, many more talented players join the club, but are we getting the best out of them ON A CONSISTENT BASIS? I am not so sure we are? Why?
The coaches have destroyed the culture and confidence of young players. They are trying to act tough by making it challenging to get game time… but promoting and omitting young players every week is the worst possible thing you can do for young players.
The coaches show no confidence in young players by dropping them after 1 game.