Recruitment of a ruckman

So W.A people,what do we have in Clarke?

New ā€œRuleā€ is interesting, ā€¦ and odd.

afl.com.au

UPDATE: Dons close to recruiting ex-Docker under new rules - AFL.com.au

Marc McGowan and Jason Phelan Nov 13, 2018 8:17PM

3-4 minutes

Ex-Docker Zac Clarke is expected to join the Bombersā€™ ruck division

ESSENDON is closing in on a back-up for No.1 ruckman Tom Bellchambers, with former Docker Zac Clarke planning to sign under new AFL rookie rules.

Both parties are waiting on the AFL to give the arrangement the green light ahead of Fridayā€™s second list lodgement deadline, because there is still confusion around how the rule works.

It could be the same situation for fellow ruckman Shane Mumford, who is set to come out of retirement for Greater Western Sydney but wants to avoid the draft.

Neither Clarke nor Mumford qualifies as a delisted free agent because theyā€™ve each had a season out of the AFL.

However, as players who were previously on an AFL list they could sign as Category A rookies between December 1 and March 15 if League headquarters gives approval.

That will depend on how the AFL officiates the rule, given it was originally reported as being introduced to help clubs cover a footballer who retires or suffers a serious, long-term injury.

Clarke, who played 101 games and kicked 46 goals for Fremantle, will have to nominate for the draft if AFL decision-makers deem him ineligible to sign that way.

The 203cm giant underwent a medical at a different club to the Bombers and was set for another one with a third club this week, so Essendon would face competition in a draft scenario.

The Dockers cut Clarke at the end of the 2017 season after two surgeries and related complications with the patella in his left knee ruined his last year there.

But the 28-year-old bounced back this year to star with eventual WAFL premier Subiaco and would fill the void at the Bombers left by the surprise retirement of Matthew Leuenberger.

NAB AFL DRAFT HUB Latest news, video and more

The Leuenberger situation may help Essendonā€™s case, with his decision to call it quits ā€“ despite having a contract in front of him ā€“ leaving it with only 20-year-old ruckman Sam Draper behind Bellchambers.

Clarke made 20 WAFL appearances and kicked 28 goals in the 2018 season, while averaging 15.7 disposals, 4.6 marks and 39 hit-outs.

He had at least 50 hit-outs in his last three matches this past season, including the Lionsā€™ Grand Final triumph over West Perth, and managed the feat twice more before that.

WHOā€™S LEAVING YOUR CLUB? All the latest retirements and delistings

The Bombers also conducted a medical on delisted Western Bulldogs big man Tom Campbell, but his search for a fresh AFL start looks set to continue.

There are other options for Campbell, with North Melbourne, Richmond, the Western Bulldogs and Adelaide among the clubs potentially on the hunt for an experienced back-up.

Helping the 42-game former Dogā€™s cause is the thin ruck depth in this yearā€™s draft market, with a little-known 205cm rugby convert, Jack Blair, surging into calculations.

INDICATIVE DRAFT ORDER Your clubā€™s latest picks

Blair, 23, is training with Sydney and AFL.com.au understands at least one Melbourne club has held discussions with his management.

West Perth lost the GF? Haha diggers

The rule complication is the afl want the giants to be able to use it but not us

23 Likes

I did wonder if the Mummy coke video made our chances of being able to use the new rule less likely. FFS its SOOOOOOO AFL to have these ambiguous rules they can exploit.

2 Likes

Rules are only ambiguous to allow for exceptions to be made for Hawthorn.

1 Like

If clarke can offer something close to what leuenburger did then Iā€™ll be satisfied with that.

Good for draper to have some competition and youā€™d hope Clarke is able to at least compete.

2 Likes

First bounce gives you an ideaā€¦

2 Likes

Hereā€™s the first bounce of the SANFL GF for comparison

LOL

2 Likes

good to see Jackets does not think Clarker is a hack

Which is what we pretty much do already.

OTOH Draper 2016, Nyuon in 2015?, SMack 2014, Thurlow 2013, Josh Jenkins 2010.

Iā€™m not convinced thereā€™s anything to be gained by worrying about ā€œtrade valueā€.
Jenkins, who was seen as surplus, got us from pick 40 to pick 30 or so.

Zac Clarke is not a physical ruckman. Heā€™s an athletic one.
His injuries have reduced how athletic he could be but he still shies away from physical contact.

If Iā€™m not mistaken, the other ruckman (Lourey) is the full forward who used to play for Frankston. Heā€™s not a full time ruckman but he loves being physical.

We should target an adequate backup ruck at some point (whether in the draft or leave a spot open to sign someone before JLT).

If Bellchambers goes down with a season ending injury in JLT, weā€™d have McKernan, Draper and Lavender to rely on until the mid season draft where we can get a better replacement. By that time, our season could be gone. If Looney didnā€™t retire, we could handle the risk.

2 Likes

I agree we need to target someone, and Clarke might be our best option, just we need to be aware that in spite of the WAFL stats heā€™s still the same player he was at Freo. Thatā€™s ok, but we have to know that and be prepared for there to be games when he gets bullied by the opposition ruck if we are forced to rely on him.

Hopefully Bellchambers status fit, and Draper comes on, and then it doesnā€™t matter.

3 Likes

Heā€™s always looked like a dandelion.

So thereā€™s 2 rucks in the ā€œdraft machineā€ database (as far as I can tell)ā€¦

Time for a Dodoro special I reckon. The Clarke story is surely spreading disinformationā€¦

I used to trust the media to tell us the truth (tell us the truth)
But now Iā€™ve seen the pay offs everywhere I look,
Who do you trust when everyoneā€™s a crook?

2 Likes

This is my understandingā€¦

But the media is stuffing you all around. That rule to take Clarke after the drafts only applies if he nominates and nobody drafts him.

  1. Firstly, in that case why on earth wouldnā€™t we draft him in the rookie draft?
  2. Secondly, why would other clubs pass? The article even says heā€™s having medical elsewhere. If they nominate him he canā€™t then play for anyone if he declined, so either way we donā€™t get him.

Iā€™m getting more confident of Williams at 34

We will pick up ruckman thatā€™s delisted currently, the fact Xavier Campbell has been open with the ruck recruitment tells me itā€™s not through the draft