Something seriously wrong with the club (Part 2, March 2022)

I’m just selecting this question to answer because it’s really easy and that doesn’t mean your questions overall don’t have merit.
Selection integrity ie earning spots is really important in sport. You pick your best team and reward players for good form.

Phillips was in a rare patch of form. He utterly deserved his spot and demanded selection in a team where the coaching group avoided playing 2 rucks like the plague since they arrived from Richmond. It also provided some foresight into how/if Bryan & Draper might fit into a team with 2MP one day.
Smith was exceptional the week before when he came on and helped changed the course of the game. Wanganeen had a good introduction and would not suffer from going back to VFL and accumulating some possessions. These selections were obvious if you are trying to win games and of course in Rd 5 we should be.

And I don’t think you’re necessarily wrong, at least not in any black/white sense.

I just think those guys being in/near the 22 speak to a club that doesn’t really accept they’re NGE, and doesn’t have a clear direction to change it.

It’s not a great look when good kids can’t get a run in a side getting flogged. Run the risk of losing them.

EDIT: to put it another way, if you look at it on a micro level, sure, Phillips in week X offers more than Bryan. In the big picture, Bryan needs to get the nod more often than not, for his development, for the good of the club. Does the club have any idea of the big picture?

He was a terrible coach… ask any cwood supporter with a brain.

1 Like

There are posts in this thread suggesting players go backwards once they walk into Essendon. I can only venture a guess as to why that would be and the conclusion I have is:

  1. Poor player development planning
  2. Training standards aren’t up to spec
  3. Game plan is crap & kills confidence

Anyone else got any other possible ideas?

What do you think the players reaction to the replay will be

Can I leave early, got to hook into my podcast.

2 Likes

You’d hope they payse of every ■■■■ effort in the second half and commit to not doing it again

Reckon these theories are always overstated…or just plain rubbish. We have assistant coaches and fitness units from across the league at Essendon. If something was drastically different, reckon that’d be noticed fairly rapidly.

Despite the perception we are miles off the top teams, I reckon you’d find the re-cycling of footy IP across teams is such that it’s a pretty close pack overall with a few front runners at any one time.

5 Likes

I’m not going to comment on club issues, I’ll concentrate on the problems with the team.

There are a lot of problems right now. I’ll start from a structural viewpoint. Our defence is seriously undersized, compounded by the fact that it’s way out of form. Laverde and Hind are not nearly the players they were last year and Ridley, forced to play more defensively, isn’t the rebound weapon of seasons past. Ball use out of the back half is poor also, and we’re missing a defensive general to organise the defence. Hurley was that man previously.

The defence’s job is made much harder by the total absence of pressure or accountability through the midfield. At the moment, there appears no interest in defensive running or more than cursory attempts at tackling. Work rate is abysmal. This is an attitude issue, not talent, and the coach has to take a share of responsibility also.

Up forward, we’re missing Walla badly for his pressure acts and ability to inject some excitement into our play. Generally speaking, we’ve lost all fizz and spontaneity this season. Wright has been good up to yesterday, but we’re definitely thin and rely on cameo efforts. Need Stringer back, and another tall.

Game style is a mess. I can’t believe that’s what the team is being coached, but what we’re seeing is slow ball movement, long kicks down the boundary, and frequent overuse by hand. There’s very little dare and no system that I can discern.

Clearly, we’re in a hole. We’re better than we’re playing, but the fact that we’re so poor atm comes back to attitude and coaching. There’s no belief and no-one is really playing as if their life depended on it. There’s obviously a big confidence issue.

I’m not about to write off the season yet. Things can turnaround quickly. I’d like to see the likes of Perkins and Hobbs get more midfield minutes to see what they’re capable of. I’m not super-impressed with Cox, but if he’s playing give him a gig on a HBF.

More than anything, the team needs a great mind shift, and it might mean some ruthless selections to ignite that. Need to get back to hard, uncompromising footy first. I’ll cop losing to Collingwood next week if we make them hurt. Right now we’re powder puffs. And play with a bit more dare. We have deficiencies - overcome them by being bold.

If they’re serious they’ll go hard in the week leading up to Anzac Day. This performance can’t be swept under the carpet. No second chances now. Play for keeps.

14 Likes

I think the inference was he was surprised at the mindset/intensity/effort of the players in training. Not the staff.





2 Likes



9 Likes

Most of that is pretty fair. The game-plan ‘paralysis’ looks real to me. Such a frustrating one for supporters outside the inner-sanctum-because publically, clubs don’t air their game strategies and where they might be failing.

Hence you get unsatisfying platitudes from the coach around ‘being better in the contest’ and ‘digging in when the momentum shifts’, which reveals little about the actual style and mechanics of the desired defensive strategy, ball-movement etc.

5 Likes

How many development years do we need?

1 Like

Zaharakis stated Bundoora train a lot harder than Essendon does.

5 Likes

We are then more farked than I thought…

1 Like

Didn’t Zaka say Bundoora train harder then Essendon?

1 Like

Yes, as stated above.

1 Like

i keep posting this picture because it sums it up perfectly

our players just don’t care / can’t be ■■■■■■ to compete

freo players running to be dangerous (and one of them, out of 4 of em, kicks the goal)

Riddley had no option but to turn it over

It’s just plain selfishness / laziness

So I ask, what the ■■■■ are you doing in the highest level of a sport if you don’t want to compete / can’t be ■■■■■■

Leave then, as you’re not worthy to don the sash

21 Likes

That’s the question that Truck needs to put on the players end of the season if you don’t want to compete or cant be fckd than pack you stuff and leave enough is enough time to get ruthless

2 Likes