Something seriously wrong with the club (Part 2, March 2022)

Sick of this nice guy stuff. Sick babying players because we don’t want to hurt their feelings. Sick of our fitness not being up to standard for years.

I want to be hated. I want to have players that get in opposition faces. I want players to care that they lose. I want our coaches to say this is not good enough in public.

It’s no fun being a team of nice guys.

I want us to spend money where it matters. Don’t get these untried people to be our fitness coaches.
Spend the money and then get the best.

Have a time limit in how long people can stay in a position at the club. Don’t let them get comfortable. Move Dodoro on. Say to the next person 5 years is all you get as a maximum unless you’ve proven to be the best. Then get someone new in.

Who cares if we annoy the media or a few players get upset. Nice clubs where you’re happy don’t always get the big names. Winning matches and flags makes you a club people want to play for and go to.
Hawks had years of not overpaying players and kept bringing in people. Why? The players wanted to win flags.

2 Likes

Club culture starts with little things like being 6 rounds into the season and still not having club photos of possibly our best player and the son of one of our greats.


15 Likes

Yeah but we at least we’ve got the Rish and Rath podcast though /s

1 Like

This irks that Fark out of me that this little stuff can’t even get done.
They didn’t bother putting a photo up for Waterman for the entire year last year.

2 Likes

“5 years is all you get maximum”
“Oh really? I’ll go to Carlton instead then”

Which “industry best” people are you expecting to attract with such policies? Lol

Key word there is “building”. There are absolutely no signs that we are building anything except lazy habits. Most supporters would be ok if we actually were building something, but we are not. We are nowhere. We have no structure, no leadership, no effort.

1 Like

5 weeks. It took just 5 f**king weeks. Screw this club.

Low crowds are noted - that killed Knights in the end

100% agree

I don’t understand what everyone’s issue is?
We have steadily climbed the ladder each week. In case you guys haven’t noticed, we started at 18th and are now 15th.
By my calculations, if we continue to get belted each week, a top 4 spot is not out of reach.
Have faith people!

18 Likes

It is hard to believe how quickly it fell apart - hope is always needed and ours left so quickly. At least in 2016 we had effort.

2 Likes

Culture is all about attitude….we have been poor in this area for far too long

There are soo many things like this that reflect poorly on the club….have a look at the reserve setup……and as also mentioned before the lack of communication to AFL club support members + not offering away reserved membership….what kind of a club are they? A selfish entitled club.

1 Like

They’re all on contracts. No one in the football department has an open ended deal.

Yes from a point of getting the best kids in i would agree with that sentiment.

What i was more referring too that with the correct structures, leadership, hard work etc, you don’t need the best players from every draft.

Gold Coast have been given some of the best players from the draft every year and have done nothing with it.

I honestly believe we have a better list compared to the following
Norf
West Coast
Adelaide
Gold Coast
Richmond
Collingwood
Hawthorn

You could argue more.

There has to be an underlying issue as to why they are all doing better than us except a few

Yep. Should have played possum in 2017.

Don’t reckon the board has the appetite for it, though.

1 Like

A friend of mine won a comp years ago and got to sit in the coaches box for a pies game.

Said Buckley is absolutely ruthless, dragged Dane Swan to the pine in one instance for losing his man and blasted him at half time.

Would take him as well

5 Likes

You’re overrating our list.
We have a better list than North and Adelaide.

The rest have enough better performed players who don’t have a massive gap between their best and worst that they’ll beat us more often than not.

You are correct though. With better coaching, getting the best out of players, great fitness regime and fantastic training, we could have a ‘some of the parts’ better team. But we’ve never been that kind of team. Not now and not in our Sheedy years. It’s always been about overwhelming the opposition with a great deal of talent (albeit mixed in with hard working role players).

If we are not seriously considering picking up the phone to Clarkson then we are doomed.

Have arguably one of the great coaches of all time potentially available for next season you go after him. Idgaf If the players like truck, you get someone who will bring results. And Clarkson is the best at that in the modern era

1 Like

5 weeks?

You must be joking… it took precisely one quarter.
One.
Whole.
Quarter…

5 Likes