Trade talk - from October 2024 (Part 7)

He said gun

6 Likes

Given our picks and Richmond’s, we will need to offer 3 firsts for Reid or 2 and a decent player.

Tiger picks are not relevant either way. If he nominates us, Tigers are out of picture. Likewise if he nominates them, it won’t matter how many picks we have.

6 Likes

Yep, good point…so Merrett then

Love your work Noober! No peer.
My take on the Ruck situation is I want Goldy rucking in the VFL. CB Focus. Building these young on ballers.
Around the ground the young blokes can cover.
I don’t think we can find a ruck mid season who can AFL Ruck most of a game?
Maybe that WA bloke?
I like the idea to get an AFL ruck on the fringe at the end of the year as back up. A bit like Goldy but younger. Or maybe a good ruckman looking for a change.

Coming around to this Reid idea given the supposed low quality of this draft, but that’ll just be an excuse from the Eagles to get more

Put a large contact in front of Shaun Mannagh to see if we can turn his head

The 5 is cursed, instant whipping boy type stuff

Not sure they need any more in the midfield, unless they think that Libba is retiring and sanders will take up the Tassie offers

Why do we do this to ourselves? I would love Reid but surely we’re just setting ourselves up for disappointment. Why would he choose us? Sure he has friends here but he’s also friends with Bailey Smith and probably half a dozen players from every other club. It would be a dream to see him in red and black but I’m afraid it’s only a pipedream.

I believe Hawthorn is moving to Dingley

I thought that was my point. Dingley and Moorabbin are the only bayside clubs.

Or…more particularly, Moorabbin isn’t the only near-bayside club.

2 Likes

I think there’s strong WA talent. So trading this year might be in the eagles interest

2 Likes

Not just friends, best friends (friend).
Has a relationship with the coach and trained at the club so knows the team.
And maybe he and his management think we’re finally taking the right steps for sustained success.
When we finally turn the corner and win some finals this will club will go crazy. Heroes will be made!!

4 Likes

I think given west coast will hold 1 and 2. If they get 2 further first rounders they may trade back something in the draft they won’t use.

So if it’s with us that could help land the academy? Kids we have on the go?

I really don’t think players will go to the eagles.

1 Like

I hope you’re right but if he goes to Geelong the melts here are going to be unprecedented.

2 Likes

Unprecedented?

Blitz is the land of melts.

6 Likes

I have a feeling if Operation Harley fails the melts will be right up there.

1 Like

West Coast have picks 1 or 2 or are you saying they have 2 firsts already? They have Hawks 1st this year which will obviously be in the teens.

I think 1 and 2 is assuming Allen gets band 1 compensation.