I still remember that game out at Homebush in 2011 where he single-handedly brought Sydney back from a 5-goal half-time deficit…and then refused to give Stanton the most blatant free-kick in the history of blatant free-kicks when Mattner pushed him fair in the back in the last minute.
Nicholls used to be putrid too, but at least he improved to being three-quarters decent, but Pannell is a deadset Karmichael Hunt.
What the analysis does not show is the frees than could have been paid and were not, looks like the raw numbers come out abut even. Where and when frees are paid or not paid seems to make a difference when viewing the games.
the worst single game of umpiring by one ump I’ve ever seen was the game we kicked 195 against Gold Coast.
Nicholls managed to pull 5 free kicks to Josh Toy (he ended up with 8) - all absolute bullshit. And he ignored 2 or 3 where he was stone cold caught. Most of the game he was matched up on Kyle Reimers, who kicked 8 goals. Gold Coast ended up ahead on the free kick count, which tells you a fair bit.
Who was the umpire(s) who didn’t call holding the ball against Gus when we beat Port at FP in 2013/14? Running into goal, took 3-4 steps so plenty of opportunity then gets caught by Baggs red handed - PLAY ON & they kick a goal to put them in front with a minute or so to go. I farking lost my mind when that happened. I had to walk out of the room screaming internally that nothing short of corruption could explain that not being called.
Ah yes, i thought we replied to take the lead back but you are right it put them within 2 points & we held them out. Would have loved to have been there!