Who will our next coach be? (Part 1)

[alex.f.94]

NFI what you’re on about, not really interested either.

[bigallan]

Check the badges awarded

[Lawry]

What did you win ?

[bigallan]

Not one single Brownie badge. Arkala was a Carlton supporter and was convinced I had a hand in that free kick against Fitzpatrick for wasting time.

[bomber_brain]

McCartney came on like a steam train but then burned through us, the dogs, dees…surely out of everyone in footy we’re not going back to that well again

[sine_nomine]

@darkknightpheonix

I think the more interesting question is, will they release all the info to the public that the process recommended hird and on what premise/basis they did so ?

You are of course wanting this public reveal for all, or any, coaches appointed.

I mean to say, you wouldn’t wish to show an antiHird bias would you?

[Drapersmullet]

@evs

But it is just straight out bizarre how many journalists are openly barracking for Brad Scott. Like Hutchy and ■■■■ literally just gave the one line TV version of Jack Niall’s article

‘journalists’ love a known quantity, IE the safe option

way easier to spew your narrative if you know how the other party is going to react

[Docca3]

Don’t get the fascination in him myself

[sine_nomine]

@Scorpio

Which part of a confidential HR process do people find so difficult to understand?

Not having any factual ammunition to mount a grandstanding grievance to the selection process and thus, no validity in the never ending accusations that the process was rigged - only rigged if Hird should win the role.

[darkknightpheonix]

@Scorpio

@darkknightpheonix

will they release all the info to the public that the process recommended hird and on what premise/basis they did so ?

Which part of a confidential HR process do people find so difficult to understand?

so they won’t release the why the decision was made ?

and people wonder why some will go with it’s a tainted process if hird gets it

[bigallan]

Now, if anyone else gets it…

[darkknightpheonix]

@Bacchusfox

I do understand that the average IQ of Australians is 99.24, it would be considerably higher if you left the country.

least you’ve upgraded your insults from, go support carlton . it’s like the only thing you could muster up as a potential insult, it was kinda sad.

[sine_nomine]

@darkknightpheonix

so they won’t release the why the decision was made ?

and people wonder why some will go with it’s a tainted process if hird gets it

Based on that argument, it’s a tainted process if anyone gets it.

[Scorpio]

@darkknightpheonix

@Scorpio

@darkknightpheonix

will they release all the info to the public that the process recommended hird and on what premise/basis they did so ?

Which part of a confidential HR process do people find so difficult to understand?

so they won’t release the why the decision was made ?

and people wonder why some will go with it’s a tainted process if hird gets it

If you think it’s a tainted process then you’re not going to accept whomever gets the role. Because it’s …… you know ……
tainted.
I don’t blame you for thinking it might be tainted, it would appear that many processes at EFC have been tainted for the past twenty years….
However this seems to be one of the first times ever in my memory they haven’t just picked someone out of thin air, and have gone to the trouble of convening a diverse qualified experienced selection panel.
And if you think the process is tainted, you are calling into question the integrity of the people on that panel.

[sine_nomine]

@darkknightpheonix

least you’ve upgraded your insults from, go support carlton . it’s like the only thing you could muster up as a potential insult, it was kinda sad.

Yeah, nah, go support fark Carlton is the highest upgrade point when you’re reaching for the lowest of low insults possible.

[darkknightpheonix]

@Scorpio

@darkknightpheonix

@Scorpio

@darkknightpheonix

will they release all the info to the public that the process recommended hird and on what premise/basis they did so ?

Which part of a confidential HR process do people find so difficult to understand?

so they won’t release the why the decision was made ?

and people wonder why some will go with it’s a tainted process if hird gets it

If you think it’s a tainted process then you’re not going to accept whomever gets the role. Because it’s …… you know ……
tainted.
I don’t blame you for thinking it might be tainted, it would appear that many processes at EFC have been tainted for the past twenty years….
However this seems to be one of the first times ever in my memory they haven’t just picked someone out of thin air, and have gone to the trouble of convening a diverse qualified experienced selection panel.
And if you think the process is tainted, you are calling into question the integrity of the people on that panel.

well again it all comes down to how many candidates they end up putting forward. if they put 3 and the club chooses hird, i won’t hold the people on the selection committee responsible.

that being said it would be valuable to know as to why a candidate is considered the best or i the best grouping, and how or what is valued as the best attributes or traits to have.

case in point (whether he applies or not) pyke is considered the supposed mastermind of the sydney attacking side of things since he’s gone there. if he was to get the job, would it be based on tactical nous first and foremost ? and x, y and z areas he may need some work on.

but yes you’re correct, i dont’ trust the efc and anyone who works day in and day out for it, to make the correct decision on Hird, I just will not ever see it as untainted.
It’d be like the police doing an audit on the police and coming back with it’s all good and all officers do everything by the book.
or dan andrews being in charge of a review of the labor party and claims of corruption and coming back with a report that says no corruption occured.
oh wait the labor zealotry on this site is just as bad as the hird zealotry …

ok new example, it’d be akin to scott morrison doing a report on how much everyone loves scott morrison and coming back with everyone does, you wouldn’t but it would you.

[chogby]

Whoever gets the gig better be bloody resilient. Going to be that much harder now.

[BOMBERBEN]

[Bully]

This whole thing about Scott saying ‘yeah if you can’t find anybody give me call’ is absurd. I reckon he is in ■■■■’s ear telling her all these things so he doesn’t look bad if he misses out, but he’s obviously keen and surely engaging with efc privately. It’s been like a month since the job became vacant, you’d know by now if you wanna coach or not.

I’d be hoping the interview team have visited him for an interview at his house or something, if as suspected he is worried about his involvement by being spotted and it being made public. You don’t wait till the last week to meet with what sounds like your number one candidate when everybody else has already had two interviews and a deadline on a decision by next Friday, it’s absolute bullshit.

[Coastalpipeline]

I’ll take 2 Chiefs & a Champ. I hate buddy & I hate being called buddy.